Selendang Ayu injustice

Jan 29, 2013, 7:00AM EST
Selendang Ayu injustice
A misuse of strict liability by the federal government

 On 6 December 2004, the bulk carrier Selendang Ayu was en route from Seattle, Washington to Xiamen, China carrying 66,000 tons of soybeans.  It also had approximately 340,000 gallons of bunkers and other petroleum products (lubricants, etc.) on board.  During a winter storm in the Bering Sea, the ship suffered a major engine casualty.  Despite the best efforts of the engineering crew, the engine could not be restarted.  The master sent a distress message to the US Coast Guard.  There were no vessels in the vicinity capable of taking the Selendang Ayu under tow.  Winds and waves pushed the ship south toward the Aleutian Chain.  The Coast Guard Cutter Alex Haley arrived on scene on 8 December but, due to the intensity of the storm, was unable to deter the movement of the much larger Selendang Ayu.  The Selendang Ayu grounded off the north shore of Unalaska Island later that day.  Using two helicopters, the Coast Guard began evacuating the 18 crewmembers.  One helicopter, with three aviators and seven Selendang Ayu crewmembers, was struck by a rogue wave as it hovered over the deck of the bulk carrier.  The helicopter crashed into the sea.  The second helicopter was able to rescue the aviators (who were wearing survival suits), but the mariners drowned.  The Selendang Ayu broke its back in the fierce winter storm, spilling its entire cargo of soybeans and its bunkers and other oils.  Several thousand seabirds died as a result of the oil spill.  The owners of the Selendang Ayu spent millions on the environmental response effort and then millions more on the removal of wreck from the isolated shore (full removal was insisted upon by the State of Alaska, which had previously allowed wrecks in similar locations to deteriorate in place).  Millions were also paid in natural resource damage claims.  None of these expenditures were wholly inappropriate.  The US Department of Justice, though, decided that criminal prosecution of the owners was necessary.  After opening the case, it could find insufficient evidence of either intentional or negligent criminal conduct.  Not deterred, DOJ filed charges against the owners for violation of the Refuse Act of 1899 (for discharging soybeans in navigable waters of the United States) and for violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (for “taking” migratory seabirds that had ingested the spilled oil).  The interesting aspect of these two charges is that the courts have interpreted these statutes as “strict liability” crimes.  This means that there is no usual criminal defense.  The owners were unable to argue that they did not intend the grounding to occur; nor could they argue that they were not negligent with regard to the grounding.  Neither argument constitutes a defense.  Left with no choice, the owners entered a plea of guilty and paid a criminal fine of $9 million.  This marks the only time in modern history that the Department of Justice has charged a shipowner solely for violation of strict liability crimes.  I, for one, hope there is no recurrence of this practice by the federal government.

Report abuse

Bookmark this page to:Add to Faves Add to MyAOL Add to Simpy Add to Delicious Add to Live Add to Digg Add to Newsvine Add to Reddit Add to Multiply Add to Blogmarks Add to Yahoo MyWeb Add to Slashdot Add to Mister Wong Add to Spurl Add to Furl Add to Link-a-Gogo Add to Yahoo Bookmarks Add to Twitter Add to Facebook Add to Diigo Add to Mixx Add to Segnalo Add to StumbleUpon Add to Magnolia Add to Ask Add to Backflip Add to Terchnorati Add to Google Bookmarks Add to MySpace

Steve Toby
One element that remains unclear in this story is whether the Selendang Ayu attempted to anchor as she was drifting towards the islands. If not, why not? If so, did the anchor drag, or the cable part? Without this element, we are left unsure if the crew really did everything in their power to avoid the grounding.
1/29/2013 1:44:28 PM
Don Bodron
They did try to anchor with both anchors.
1/31/2013 1:42:05 PM